11/30/2022 0 Comments The expanse episode 1![]() ![]() #The expanse episode 1 tvNot necessarily in terms of keeping faithful to the source material, but just in terms of being an engaging TV show period. While I think the WoT show is decent (6.5/10), I also think it's doing a noticeably poorer job than The Expanse (so far 8.5/10 for me). I'm a WoT fan, and that really affects my perspective when I look at The Expanse. But it's within the realm of internal consistency for her show character. ![]() #The expanse episode 1 plusPlus the conflict drags on for too long for my enjoyment. I still think what she did was bullshit, and I wish they hadn't forced that plotline into the show. Honestly, I do still prefer book Naomi by a long shot, but I'm planning a re-listen again soon so I'm not too bummed about missing out on that portrayal on TV.ĭisagree about it being "Sorry, not sorry." That'd be more along the lines of "I'm sorry you got your feelings hurt" or "I'm sorry you can't understand why I did it." I can't really imagine how she could have apologized more authentically, without backpedaling on her own convictions. It definitely changes her from the books. Again I think, the strenght of the show, is that it doesn't judge. And plenty of others that are very frustrated by it. I've talked to a lot of people that are really sympathetic to Naomi's decision there. And sometimes people may be more sympathetic to other mistakes, again shaped by their own views. People sometimes notice the flaws of certain characters more than others (often shaped by their own views) which rubs them the wrong way. Nor does it unnecessarily rag on them for doing what they thought was right. The strenght of the show, is that it doesn't give characters an easy out when they make unilateral decisions like this. The decision has both good and bad repercussions. Her decision came from wanting the best for the Belt, a group of people that she rightly feels always draw the short straw. A lot of her strengths and best moments as a character stem from this aspect of her character too. Naomi can be rash sometimes and she certainly makes emotional decisions at times. Almost everything every character does makes sense from their point of view during the situation they found themselves in, but objectively it may not always have been the best choice. That's a conscious writing decision, and very unique in television. The fact is every character is flawed in various ways. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |